Grace believed she understood the pattern—her sister only reached out when she needed financial help. But when a small detail leads Grace to follow a trail of online clues, she realizes Samantha’s struggles might be more complex than just owing money.
I stared longer than necessary at the message on my phone: “Hey sis! Can you lend me $500? I wouldn’t ask if I had another option.”
It was the same old Samantha, with the same worn-out plea, like a broken record.
I let out a quiet scoff and set the phone down on the kitchen counter. The usual frustration bubbled inside me, but beneath that was a sharper ache.
We used to be inseparable—like two halves of the same heart.
But at some point, Samantha stopped wanting me in her life except when her wallet was empty.
Maybe we’d grown too different. My life was ordered, steady, and sensible—I had a husband coaching Little League, two kids with matching lunchboxes, and a steady job with benefits.
Meanwhile, Samantha just drifted—nothing seemed to stick for her, nothing seemed to matter.
“Everything okay?” Tom asked from the kitchen table where he was helping Emma with homework.
“It’s Sam,” I said, showing him the message. “She needs money again.”
He raised an eyebrow but didn’t say a word. His silence was a judgment in itself.
“I know what you’re thinking,” I said.
“I didn’t say anything.” He turned back to Emma’s math worksheet.
“You didn’t have to.”
I typed back, “Last time.”
Even as I sent it, the lie tasted bitter. It was never the last time with Samantha.
The typing bubbles appeared, then: “Thank you. Love you.”
I opened my cash app to send the money and noticed something odd—her requests came around the same time each month, always for the same amount.
Probably just coincidence, I told myself, and transferred the money.
But the thought lingered.
Later that night, after the kids were asleep, I found myself telling Tom, “Sam’s requests always come between the 9th and 11th every month. It’s been like that for over a year.”
Tom closed the dishwasher quietly. “You’re like her paycheck.”
I laughed, but it was a cracked, tired laugh. “Yeah, she’s like a bill I never agreed to.”
What I didn’t say was how much it hurt that this was all we’d become—transactions instead of the late-night talks and shared secrets of our childhood.
Dad used to call Samantha the wild one and me the responsible one, like it was a medal.
But all I ever wanted was someone to lean on.
The more I succeeded, the further Samantha seemed to drift. I wondered if she resented me—or if she just didn’t care.
“You should ask her directly what’s going on,” Tom suggested.
I messaged her, “Is everything okay? This is a pattern—$500 every month.”
Her reply was quick: “Just short on rent again. I know I suck.”
I showed Tom. “That’s deflection.”
He shrugged. “You sent the money. That’s what she wanted.”
He was right. That should’ve been the end.
But that night, after Tom fell asleep with his arm around me, I did something I’d promised myself I wouldn’t—I checked up on Samantha online.
Her profile was private and barely updated—just a blurry photo from our teens, arms around each other in swimsuits.
I remembered that summer. Dad was always “working” or pretending to. He’d grunt from the recliner and hand over money instead of hugs.
Samantha used to joke, “He thinks parenting is just paying the rent on kids.”
I used to laugh. Now it felt painfully true.
When did we stop being on the same team?
Scrolling further, I found a post on a friend’s page tagging Samantha at a community fundraiser for Green Meadow Hospice.
In the photo, Samantha wasn’t posing or smiling—she was working hard, sleeves rolled up, packing food and gift bags.
The caption read: “@Samantha helped make this happen! Thanks for always showing up for our community’s most vulnerable.”
The fundraiser was just two days after she last borrowed money. Was that a coincidence? It didn’t seem like one.
My stomach tightened. What was she really doing there?
I tried to sleep but couldn’t shake the image of carefree Samantha working those tables—a stranger to me now.
The next day, I called in sick to work, telling Tom I was meeting an old friend—a small lie that felt heavy.
I drove an hour to Green Meadow Hospice, heart pounding. If Samantha was there again following the same schedule, she’d be back soon.
The hospice was smaller than I’d imagined, smelling faintly of lavender and cleaner.
At the front desk, a gray-haired woman typed quietly.
“Hi,” I said, steadying my voice. “My sister Samantha comes here regularly?”
The receptionist smiled. “Yes, she’s here now. Room 14. You can go in.”
I hadn’t expected that. I nodded and walked down the quiet hallway, carpet muffling my steps.
At Room 14, the door was ajar. I peeked inside.
Samantha sat at a bedside, looking tired but calm, hair tied back, a coffee cup on the windowsill. She was holding a man’s hand.
At first, I barely looked at the man—thin, hooked up to oxygen, anyone’s grandfather maybe.
But then something familiar struck me. I leaned closer.
It was our father—the man I hadn’t seen or spoken to in 12 years.
He was smaller, frail, not the imposing figure I remembered—the man who once told me to toughen up or leave, who never said he was proud of me.
When I was eight, after a nightmare, it was Samantha who comforted me, not him. She was always the soft place; I learned to be steel.
I froze, barely breathing.
Then Samantha looked up, our eyes met.
Her expression softened—something I hadn’t seen in a long time—and it broke me.
Dad turned to me, eyes watery but alert, recognition flickering.
“You came,” he whispered.
That cold, stoic man smiled at me like I was the sun.
I swallowed hard. “I didn’t know I was supposed to. You could’ve told me.”
“Grace,” Samantha said, standing, “I was going to. Eventually.”
“Eventually,” I repeated bitterly. “How long has he been here?”
“Eight months,” Dad answered, weak.
“Eight months? And no one thought to call me?”
Samantha flushed. “I tried last Christmas. You said you were busy.”
“I was busy for a call, not for this.” I gestured at the IV, pills, everything.
Dad coughed.
“How bad is it?” I asked.
“I’m dying,” he said simply, like stating a fact.
I looked at Samantha. “The money—you borrowed every month—was for this?”
She nodded. “For his meds, extra care. Insurance doesn’t cover it all. I had to cut back at work to be here.”
“So you’ve been playing nurse? Volunteering here?”
“Yes.”
I couldn’t look at either of them. My eyes burned, but I wouldn’t cry.
Samantha stood. “I’ll leave you two alone. Need anything before I go?”
Dad shook his head. “No, honey. Thank you.”
“Honey.” The word hit me—he never called us that.
Dad said, “I tried the only way I knew—providing, teaching you to be strong. My father never spoke to me unless I was wrong. I thought I was different because I spoke to you.”
The bar was low, and barely met.
“When you left,” he added, “I was proud of you—for having courage I never had.”
“Courage?”
“To walk away from someone who hurt you.”
Something inside me cracked, years of hurt and anger flooding through.
“I didn’t want to leave. I wanted a reason to stay.”
Dad closed his eyes. For a moment, I thought he was slipping away. Then he opened them—wet with tears.
“I’m sorry, Grace. So sorry.”
The apology I never thought I’d hear.
Later, outside in the garden, I found Samantha on a bench. She didn’t look up but made room beside her.
“You could’ve told me,” I said.
Samantha didn’t meet my eyes. “I figured…”
Leave a Reply